Skip to content
Nutri Inspector

The Ultimate Guide to Beverage Sweeteners

By Cindy Wilson

BS, Dietetics and Nutrition

Published · 5 min read

The bottom line

Sugar substitutes contribute only a few or no calories to the diet and generally will not raise blood sugar levels, the FDA says. Sweeteners authorized by the FDA are safe for the general population under certain conditions of use. Sugars from syrups and honey count as added sugars.

Key takeaways

  • The Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommends limiting calories from added sugars to less than 10 percent of total calories per day.
  • Added sugars do not include naturally occurring sugars that are found in milk, fruits, and vegetables.
  • Aspartame contains calories but is about 200 times sweeter than table sugar. People with phenylketonuria (PKU) should avoid or restrict aspartame.
  • Whole-leaf and crude stevia extracts are not permitted for use as sweeteners in the U.S. The FDA has not objected to certain highly purified steviol glycosides.
  • Do not feed honey to a child who is younger than 1 year old. Honey can contain the bacteria that cause botulism.

Many of our beloved drinks contain artificial or natural sweeteners, a fundamental component.  They give taste and texture, and sweeten beverages.  When creating and developing their products, beverage companies must undertake due research to choose the appropriate sweetener.

Beverage sweeteners alter your product’s whole taste, nutrition, and price by varying in cost, mouthfeel, texture, and calorie content. When choosing a sweetener, you should weigh shelf life, production cost, health advantages, and other factors. This is a guide to assist you in understanding the several kinds of beverage sweeteners, their variations, and things to consider while selecting.

the ultimate guide to beverage sweeteners

Common Drink Sweeteners Terminology

Sweeteners are usually utilized when choosing beverages, including added sugar, mouthfeel, total sugar, glycemic load, texture, and caloric value. Knowing these words and their subtleties is essential since they affect your food’s taste and nutritional content.

  • Added sugar is a sweetener put into beverages during manufacturing, primarily to improve taste and texture. Added sugar excludes naturally occurring sugars from vegetables, dairy, and fruits. According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, added sugars must be stated on the Nutrition Facts label. This enables consumers to make wise decisions. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans advise keeping added sugars to less than 10% of your daily calorie count.
  • The drink’s naturally occurring and has added sugar content. You should show this figure on the Nutrition Facts label.
  • The texture of a beverage (its thickness, density, slipperiness, and smoothness) is what one experiences in the mouth. It imparts to your product its special taste, texture, and character. The sweetener determines the mouthfeel; some give a thinner and smoother texture while others generate a thicker and heavier sensation. To balance the texture and taste of their beverages, drinkers are combining many sweeteners more and more.
  • The glycemic load of a food is its carbohydrate count. This increases your blood sugar level. A low glycemic load is ideal for people attempting to control their blood sugar levels. It helps control chronic conditions. These include obesity, diabetes, and heart disease. 
  • Artificial sweeteners contribute only a few or no calories; naturally occurring sugars have the highest caloric burden.

Developing your product’s perfect taste and texture depends on knowing how these words relate to choosing beverage sweeteners. It also facilitates the learning of the several elements influencing your choice of beverage sweetener.

Factors Affecting Sweetener Selection

Complex drink formulation requires full knowledge of form, ph level, flavour, caloric value, texture, and cost-effectiveness. Many times, the choice of a sweetener has long-term effects. Think through these elements while choosing a sweetener:

Flavor Profile

Sweeteners vary in flavor. Artificial sweeteners can have a metallic or harsh aftertaste; natural sugars offer a moderate sweetness. To produce the perfect taste, you must balance flavour with a sweetener. Sweeteners also affect the general taste by reacting differently under heat or light.

Growing consumer demand for better products has raised knowledge of how much beverage sweeteners affect human health. Artificial sweeteners contribute only a few or no calories and have no nutritional benefit; natural sweeteners have more value. 

Health Information and Safety 

Natural sweeteners should be used sparingly since they can have large sugar and calorie counts that raise blood sugar levels. Artificial sweeteners are approved for use in food and beverage goods and are under FDA monitoring for safety.

Ensuring your product achieves consumer taste expectations and meets safety and health criteria depends on choosing the appropriate sweetener. Knowing the subtleties of every sweetener and how they will impact the: 

  • Flavor
  • Texture
  • Manufacturing cost
  • Shelf life
  • Health profile of your product is crucial

Knowing this will enable you to choose the sweetener that best suits your product.

Costs of Producing Beverage Sweeteners

Prices for sweeteners range a lot. Natural sweeteners, such as agave, honey, and maple syrup, are usually more expensive than fake ones because they are harder to get and require more complicated methods to extract. Artificial sweeteners can save you money, but you may need other ingredients to improve the taste or texture.

Shelf Life

The shelf life of your product is its expected freshness and flavor retention duration. Sweeteners can impact shelf life; some may not be appropriate for goods with higher expectations of shelf life. Some sweeteners break down more quickly under heat and light. This reduces shelf life. Natural sweeteners could develop off-flavours over time and often have a shorter shelf life than synthetic sweeteners.

Natural Sweeteners for Drinks

Natural sweeteners in beverages can provide a clean label and appeal to health-conscious consumers. They are usually taken from fruits or plants, naturally occurring sweets. They consist of:

  • Sugar is the most obvious natural sweetener and the standard by which other sweeteners are measured. Its taste, texture, and mouthfeel are instantly pleasing. Sugar boasts the highest glycemic load and four calories per gram. For clients seeking low-calorie or calorie-free choices, it’s not perfect.
  • Honey: Low glycemic load and tremendous nutritional value make honey a natural sweetener for organic, health-conscious products, becoming increasingly popular. It has 3.3 calories per gram and a distinctly earthly taste. Honey accentuates the taste character of your drink and is an excellent choice for organic, health-conscious products. Although it has a great shelf life, putting it in a drink increases its susceptibility to darkening, loss of intensity, and development of off-flavours. Working with honey calls for especially cautious attention and mindfulness.
  • Agave: Derived from the blue agave plant, agave is becoming popular because of its high solids content, low glycemic index, and neutral taste. Its mild and delicate sweetness will give a drink individuality. A great substitute for honey, agave performs nicely in low-calorie beverages. In its dry form, it has a shelf life of up to two years; but, coupled with a beverage and kept improperly, it darkens and starts turning sour.
  • Maple syrup: Because of its vitamins, high antioxidant content, minerals, and low glycemic index, maple syrup, a natural sweetener, is becoming increasingly popular in many regions. It has three calories per gram and tastes clearly like caramel. Used in beverages, it could complicate the flavor profile.

Formulating a beverage requires considering the financial consequences of adding natural sweeteners. Natural sweeteners might not be the most affordable option and could grow costly. 

Endnote 

Your taste profile, cost concerns, and personal preferences will all affect the sweeteners you use for your beverage items. Working with an experienced beverage product developer will help you avoid all that effort by guiding you through the choosing process; the ideal approach is to experiment with several sweeteners and combinations until you discover the one that works for you.

See all